The aftermath of Sherriff Lucas's rescue is at hand. Special Agent Racine arrives for an investigation and holds a hearing for all the parties.
Carrie is sentenced to 30 days in prison. Meanwhile, tensions rise between the Longshadows and Proctors.
A Kinaho girl is killed on Amish territory, and Proctor comes to help his people. Meanwhile, Hood is surprised by a visitor from his past.
Lucas interrogates a notoriously violent and radical Amish teacher in an attempt to solve the crime.
Carrie gets out of prison, and Lucas is waiting for her, however, he believes someone is following them.
Gordon and Deva realize Carrie's presence in their lives is vital. Meanwhile, Proctor gives Rebecca a lesson in loyalty.
Hood is hunting down Proctor after realizing that the latter was behind Jason's death. Gordon and Carrie examine their choices.
Job finds a lead on where Rabbit is staying, while Carrie receives money to treat Max.
In New York, Rabbit is hiding in a church, while Lucas and Carrie get ready for a big confrontation, and the fate of Emmett is uncovered.
Proctor is released from prison and Rebecca's loyalty is in question. Meanwhile, Lucas and Carrie prepare for their face-off with Rabbit.