Ichabod Crane, a soldier serving under General George Washington, dies in battle after slaying the Headless Horseman, both falling together. Over two centuries later, Ichabod awakens when a dark force resurrects the Horseman, their fates bound by shared blood. Police Lieutenant Abbey Mills...Read more investigates the murders, uncovering two opposing forces, one of light, the other of darkness.
One of Ichabod's most ardent enemies arrives in Washington to threaten the safety of high-ranking officials. Both Ichabod and Jenny believe some magic is driving their latest case. Also, after the death of Abbie Mills, Ichabod and Jenny begin searching for the next witness.