Wrongfully accused of murder, Madeline Scot struggles with the prosecutor who got her imprisoned in order to free an innocent man.
When Tamara Folsom, a rape victim, is accused of murder, The Injustice Defense Group starts an investigation. Meanwhile, Madeline tries to help Levi, but a secret from his past threatens to thwart her attempts. Easy struggles as he attempts to synchronize his work life and his family life.
The team is recruited to demand a retrial for a man who was accused of murder when he was but a 14-year-old boy. In order to take revenge on Madeline, Bellows takes advantage of Rosemary's family for his best interest.
Easy gets torn between his own faith and the general good when Madeline is assigned a case of a woman who's accused of murdering her newborn child.
The team has a disagreement over whether they should help a white supremacist out of a dilemma, with Madeline deciding to help him. Meanwhile, Bellows must contend with making a pivotal decision, and Levi continues his investigations to find out who embroiled him in Rosemary's death.
The team takes on a case where a girl is accused of matricide. Meanwhile, Madeline gets drawn into a vicious circle of dramatic revelations as she tries to halt Bellows' activities, improve her relationship with Dylan, and make peace with some shocking news.
Madeline embarks on a journey with Amina Jackson, a civil rights activist, to acquit a man accused of murdering a police officer. Madeline tries to save Levi from an unpleasant situation, with Sanchez and Bellows trying to turn tables on both.
When Cindy Whitman gets accused of killing her trans-friend, Vanessa, the team does their damndest to acquit her. Meanwhile, new evidence regarding Rosemary's death emerges, and Madeline makes peace with a certain aspect of her identity that she kept hidden from her loved ones.
In an attempt to exonerate a frat boy, the team is approached to help with accusations of rape and murder directed at him. Meanwhile, a new lead on the Davon Watkins' case urges Madeline to travel to Ohio.
Madeline and the team try to exonerate a Navy SEAL accused of murdering her senior. Meanwhile, Levi tries to find out more about Rosemary's high school life, while Bellows decides to investigate her murder.
The team is assigned a new case where a mother is accused of causing the death of her infant baby. Madeline and Levi find more information about Rosemary's past. Meanwhile, Bellows resumes his plan to send Madeline back to jail.
Easy is assigned a new case where an immigrant is accused of murder. Meanwhile, the team intensifies their investigation regarding Rosemary's murder, while Madeline and Bellows face off against each other.
Madeline gets in trouble and the team tries to band together to solve Rosemary's death before it's too late. Meanwhile, new evidence and old feuds resurface, threatening to thwart Bellows' achievements.