After returning from China, Jesse is surprised to receive a video that could tarnish his reputation. Meanwhile, Eli resumes his plans to grow the Gemstone empire, even while still mourning the death of his wife.
Jesse takes his friends on a trip as he tries to explain to them the strange oddities of the night before, especially after they reminisce about a family member.
Baby Billy makes a shocking return with his much younger wife, Tiffany. Meanwhile, Jesse tries to find out who his blackmailers are.
Gideon goes behind the scenes of Gemstone. Kelvin is tasked with carrying out a sweep for Dot, a rebellious teen, who is also the daughter of the most generous church donor.
A flashback to 1989 showcases Aimee-Leigh's pregnancy, as the friends have a hard time dealing with the news. Meanwhile, Eli tries to advance the prospects of his family.
Judy seeks Baby Billy's tutelage to help her rise into stardom, just like Kelvin. Jesse finds a lead that might just help him uncover the identity of his blackmailers.
Eli tells Kelvin, Judy, and Jesse that he needs them to be present for Easter Sunday Service. Judy's connection with and reference for Baby Billy threatens her own relationships and the unity of her family.
Jesse must deal with the aftermath of the dramatic Sunday Easter. Meanwhile, Judy has a change of heart after Baby Billy criticizes her, and she tries to mend things with BJ.
Eli is unsure about his children's future with the Gemstone. Meanwhile, Jesse struggles in an attempt to save his marriage, and Judy tells BJ more about her past.