As the family man Scott Perry learns of his terminal cancer diagnosis, he decides to secure the future of his five children by enlisting the help of three of his friends to act as father figures for his kids after he passes away.
As Luly meets her biological mother, she finds out about how Scott raised her on his own while she was little. Robin is having doubts about the 'council of dads', as she worries that it might not work considering how each member is dealing with their own issues.
Luly tries to excel in her writing group by using her personal experience for inspiration. Luly's husband, Evan, is considering going back to school. Robin becomes at a loss after Larry makes her a surprising offer.
Robin tries to move on after Scott's passing. Luly and Evan decide to use their loan money in a high-risk investment. As Anthony is getting ready for the transformation of the Crab Shack, he forms an unexpected friendship.
As Scott's family and friends are having a hard time getting through many holidays and events like Thanksgiving and Christmas, Robin starts to get closer to Sam.
Perry's family and friends face unsettling news, after Scott and Robin's adopted daughter, Charlotte, becomes in need of urgent heart surgery.
Things take an unexpected turn when Scott's best friend, Anthony, receives a job offer in Las Vegas, which could jeopardize his position in the 'council of dads'.
Robin starts to have strong feelings for Sam in spite of her hectic life. Luly is in shock after the council tells her startling news about her father.
As a storm approaches their neighborhood, the Perry family takes shelter. After her blog gets published, Luly grapples to deal with the consequences, as she lends Larry a hand to mend his relationship with his daughter and granddaughter.
Dr. Oliver helps to deliver Sage's baby as she goes into labor. As the storm rages on, Anthony manages to rescue Robin and Theo, while the fate of the Crab Shack hangs in the balance.