Bobby, the candy-obsessed, is leaving, yet it's really hard on the Creek Kids, who decide to reminisce about their moments with Bobby. However, they realize they never actually spent so much time with him.
As Craig's hair is causing him trouble, he gives himself a haircut, which turns out to be pretty awful, whereupon he decides to disguise himself as a cool kid named Jacob.
When Craig finds out from Bobby that the Honeysuckle Rangers have sneaked into the Creek to seize his map, he decides to create a fake one to misguide them.
When Barry abandons the Elders' campaign owing to Mark's injustice, Kelsey joins, only to discover that her creativity is not welcomed, upon which the Stump Kids resolve to try to reunite the Elders.
Craig accepts the Sucker Pucker Challenge in which he has to suck on a sour lemon treat without chewing in order to win. On the other hand, Big Red, the former record holder, plots to ensure that Craig loses the challenge at any rate.
As Craig develops a pink eye infection and is forced to stay at home, Nicole recommends that she and Craig make a pillow fort, much to Craig's delight that he did not want the day to end.
When the Honeysuckle Rangers steal Craig's map to send it to their king, things quickly spin out of control, upon which the Green Poncho helps the Stump Kids to sneak into the Other Side undercover to retrieve their map.
As the summer is coming to an end, Craig chooses to keep a firefly so he may make a wish later, as a result of which he gets sick, prompting him to make a wish as soon as possible.
When Bernard messes up the restroom Craig just cleaned, Craig vows to exact vengeance by going with his friends to the restaurant where Bernard works and acting as obnoxious customers, but Craig soon feels bad about what he did.
Robyn and the Snow Sword is Kelsey's first novel that she thinks should be published, so she, Craig, J.P., and Stacks spread many copies all over the library, but Kelsey chooses to have all of her books destroyed after overhearing someone saying they didn't enjoy it.
The Creek Kids begin to play the circle game, which rapidly becomes a source of annoyance for everyone, upon which Craig establishes the Council of the Creek to bring back order to the game.
When Kelsey, Craig, and J.P. arrive at the stump, they are met by Sparkle Cadet, an outer space magical hero who agrees to assist them in ridding Kelsey of her negativity.
When things between Craig and his cousin, Bryson, get awkward, he takes him to the Creek to spend some time. Meanwhile, Duane is jealous when Jessica grows more attracted to his brother, Darnell.
The Stump Kids encounter Roxie, a girl who ran away from Sleepaway Camp. As they try to help her, Craig discovers that Roxie lied to them about everything, which puts Craig and his friends in danger.
An unintentional stink bomb explosion forces the Stump Kids to ask everyone to leave the Creek, but matters get worse when Wren tries to clear the air.
As he prepares for the fifth grade, Craig adopts a tadpole and plans to take care of it until it becomes a frog, but this makes Craig worries how growing up would affect him.
As the Stump Kids find out that there's a small doll living inside a dollhouse, they're taken aback when they find it following them, whereupon they enlist the help of the Witches of the Creek and Stacks.
As the Williams family gathers for Thanksgiving, Bernard inadvertently smashes their mother's homemade sweet potato pie, while Craig tries to save the day.
Craig and his sister Jessica both volunteer at the Creek Daycare, but Craig gets angry when Jessica outperforms him in child care.
As the King stockpiles candy, the Honeysuckle Rangers enlist the assistance of the Stump Kids in order to smuggle sweets in the Creek. However, the King's BFF, Maya, notices their plan and begins to tighten the noose on them.
Craig and Kelsey are invited to J.P.'s place for a sleepover. The Creek, on the other hand, starts a game of flashlight tag. Although they're having a good time, J.P. wants to go back home, but things take an unexpected turn when they get tagged.
While J.P. and Maney prepare for the Tea Timers' dance party at the Creek, Craig suspects that it is a plot to get vengeance on him.
The Stump Kids come across an underground bunker built of cardboard by Carter Brown. As they go down, with Zoe's help, they learn that Carter has been attempting to make up for his previous wrongdoings by bettering himself.
The Stump Kids stumble upon Founder's Keep, a hidden subterranean bunker, which they assume belonged to the first group of kids who lived in the Creek in 1976.
The Stump Kids decide to explore the Algae Abyss, but they lose their paddle and become trapped there, whereupon Kelsey sends Mortimor to seek assistance.
When Craig becomes upset about Kelsey and J.P.'s disrespect for his affairs, he reaches out to the Keeper of Secrets to alleviate his burden.
As Craig is forced to repay Kit after mistakenly destroying her whole stock of red velvet choco rolls, Kit makes him conduct trades for her the whole day.
When the Stump Kids pay a visit to the Elders at the Elder Rock, they find that the Elders have been stuck beneath the rock for five days, whereupon Craig and Kelsey try to save them.
Kelsey unintentionally destroys a wall with her sword while playing at Craig's place, as a result of which she gets punished by Neil, her father, who takes her sword away. Later, she enlists Craig and J.P.'s help to restore her sword.
As Craig attempts to figure out what led the Ancients of the Creek to dissolve, he stumbles upon important information with the help of Kelsey and J.P.
In this musical episode, Craig is trapped inside the house as it is raining outside, upon which he decides to create a fictional adventure for himself and his buddies.
After failing for many years to convince his family to adopt a dog, Craig is now given the chance again, only if he follows Fredite Brigid in her three-step program.
Jessica, Craig's younger sister, hosts her own TV program, saves Kelsey's sword, trains to be the finest video gamer, struggles with a loose tooth, and goes too far with the rules of a family game.
When a ferret is discovered in the Creek, Kelsey joins forces with Stacks and Wildernessa to track it down, but Kelsey rapidly grows jealous when she feels she's being neglected.
As Craig and the Green Poncho journey to the Other Side of the Creek, Craig discovers the startling history of the Green Poncho.
As Craig fails to remember his childhood of which his mother tries to remind him, he decides to make a time capsule to save all of his favorite moments so as not to forget them one day.
Wren enlists the help of the Stump Kids to figure out why the salt levels have risen, and as they make their way down to the rapids, they're shocked to discover that a monster is going after them.
When Craig, Kelsey, and J.P. learn that a little girl called Paloma has been jinxed for a whole year, they try to help her, only for an enraged Paloma to start jinxing everyone in the Creek in retaliation for being neglected for so long.