After getting out of prison, a con man in his 30s adopts Pete's persona. He moves in with Pete's long-distance, unknowing family and is forced to work at the law firm run by the family. While working with them, he will learn about the family life he never had.
When their business is at risk, Otto and Audrey become more tense. While Marius suggests a bold move to help Julia handle a difficult customer, he recalls how he and Vince came to be rivals.
As Marius tries to make it to his parole officer appointment, he must elude Pete's nosy cousins and an ambush. When Eddie reaches his breaking point, Katie decides to help Marius.
Marius finds it difficult to manipulate Pete's family after being tempted by the prospect of a large payout in the safe at the bail bondsman's office, particularly Taylor, who has a short fuse and a well-guarded secret. Vince has a difficult client to deal with.
Marius discovers something important, while Audrey and Otto have an argument. Meanwhile, Julia stirs up her romance with her ex, Lance, and Vince offers Eddie a new position. Carly confronts her strange relative about his history.
Marius enlists the assistance of younger talent when Otto meets old pals on the nearby reservation out of fear of reprisals. Meanwhile, Carly reveals a secret about Pete, and Julia needs to determine if she can trust Lance once more.
Audrey tries to save the business while Otto is adamant about doing things his way. Carly questions Marius with what she revealed, and he tries to establish his new identity by visiting people from his past. Elsewhere, Winslow tracks down Katie and her family.
As Marius is attempting to recover funds from a deceptive deal, Otto moves forward with a risky scheme. Meantime, Katie and Brendon have a tied-up police detective in their basement.
As Otto's plan goes sideways, Dockery asks for the money back. After escorting Marius into the woods with Dockery's permission, Winslow wants to kill the former.
When Marius starts playing poker at Vince's table, Vince grows skeptical. Meanwhile, Julia tries to save Lance, and Audrey encounters a horrifying crime scene.