When an 11-year-old boy is murdered, detective Ralph Anderson starts his investigation, and the evidence leads to the baseball coach Terry Maitland.
Glory tries to calm her daughter Jessa, who says there is a man who came to her room at night.
Ralph continues to look over the circumstances surrounding the night of the murder, while Jack discovers key evidence.
Holly follows a possible connection to a case similar to the Maitlands', while Glory's personal life is under scrutiny.
After returning from a trip to New York, Holly searches for evidence in several locations related to the Dayton case.
Holly believes that there is a connection between the Frankie Peterson case and two other child murders, and Yunis wants to investigate Claude who was the last person to have been in contact with Terry.
Holly tries to help the unstable Jack, while Ralph and Alec are tracking their location. Glory is considering Howie's suggestion regarding how to ensure the financial future of her family.
In an attempt to prevent another murder, Holly, Ralph, Yunis, and Andy follow Claude as he reconnects with his brother in Tennessee.
As they conceal their real purpose from the local police, Ralph and Yunis interview witnesses from the cave festival, while Andy and Holly examine the crime scene.
The team finds themselves in a very difficult situation, and Hayes holds a press conference to clarify Terry's position and reopen the Frankie case.